A week after the storm, a stranger climbs a ladder onto your roof, walks around for twenty minutes, takes photos, and leaves. A few days later a letter arrives: approved, partly approved, or denied. What happened in those twenty minutes decides the outcome — and most of it is knowable before they ever show up.
First: was it one storm, or years of wear?
This is the question that decides most claims. Insurance pays for sudden damage — hail on Tuesday, wind on Friday night. It does not pay for a roof that simply got old. So the adjuster starts by dating the damage. They check the storm records for your address, look at whether the hits are fresh (bright, unweathered marks where hail knocked the granules off) or old and greyed, and compare the damaged slopes with the sheltered ones. Fresh hits on the windward slope and nothing on the back slope tells a storm story. The same wear on every slope tells an age story. If you can name the storm — the date, the hail size — say so. A date makes their job easy.
Second: how bad is it, really?
Adjusters do not count feelings; they count damage. On a hail claim they look at how many hits land in a test square — a 10-by-10-foot patch of roof — and whether the hits broke through the shingle surface or just scuffed it. A dozen soft dents that did not crack anything may be called cosmetic, which many policies no longer pay for. Missing shingles, lifted tabs, cracked tiles, and torn flashing are harder to argue with: the roof cannot keep water out, and that is what the policy is for. Wind damage has its own tell. A few shingles gone from one edge is a repair. Shingles lifted across a whole slope, with the seal broken underneath, means the wind got under the roof system. Take your own photos before the adjuster arrives, from the ground and from the attic if you can get up there safely. A water stain on the attic boards, dated the day you found it, is worth more than a paragraph of description.
Third: how old is the roof?
Age decides how much of the repair the insurer pays for. A standard shingle roof lasts about 20 to 25 years. On a 7-year-old roof, a covered claim usually pays close to the full cost of the repair. On a 22-year-old roof, the insurer subtracts depreciation — the value the roof has already used up — and the check shrinks. Many policies pay in two parts: a first check for the depreciated value, minus your deductible, and the rest once the work is done and invoiced. That second part only arrives after the roof is fixed, so keep every invoice. Deductibles on roof claims often run $1,000 to $2,500, or 1 to 2 percent of the home's insured value. On a $300,000 home, a 2 percent deductible is $6,000 out of your pocket before the policy pays a dollar. Know your number before the adjuster arrives.
What to have ready before they arrive
Four things, none of them hard. The date of the storm and what it did. Photos of the damage, taken as soon as it was safe, plus photos of the same roof from before the storm if you have them. A roofer's written note describing what is damaged and what it will take to fix it — not a sales pitch, a plain list. And your policy's deductible and roof coverage, which is one phone call to your agent. Do not repair anything before the adjuster sees it, except a tarp to stop water coming in — emergency cover-ups are expected and never held against you. If your roofer can be there during the visit, let them be.
What gets a claim turned down
The common denials are almost all avoidable. Wear and tear, with no storm to blame. Damage already there from a storm two years ago that nobody filed on — insurers pay for the storm that caused it, and the clock runs out. Cosmetic-only hail marks on a policy that excludes them. And waiting too long: most policies give you a year or so to file, but the longer you wait, the harder it is to tie the damage to one storm. If the answer is no, ask for the denial in writing with the exact reason. A second look with your roofer present, or a written repair estimate that itemizes the storm damage separately from the wear, can move a claim that was denied on a thin first visit.
See your roof the way a roofer does — free.
Start with a free aerial exam of your roof: a full look at every slope, with a plain-English report of what is damaged and what it will take to fix it. If it needs a closer look, book a free in-person inspection — schedule online at Tryroofrover.com.
Get My Free Aerial Exam →The bottom line
The adjuster is not guessing — they are matching your damage to one storm, counting how bad it is, and checking the roof's age against it. Name the storm, photograph the damage before it is touched, keep the roofer's written note, and know your deductible. Do that, and the twenty minutes on your roof work for you instead of against you.