Two houses on the same street, both re-roofed last spring: one in architectural shingles for about $12,000, the other in standing-seam metal for about $24,000. Ask which owner got the better deal and you are asking the wrong question — both did, on different timelines.
What each one costs
Price is where the two part ways first. Architectural shingles — the thick, layered shingles on most American houses — run about $4.50 to $7 per square foot installed, as a ballpark; every roof differs. A standing-seam metal roof runs about $10 to $16 per square foot installed. On a 2,000-square-foot roof, that is roughly $9,000 to $14,000 in shingles against roughly $20,000 to $32,000 in metal. Screw-down metal panels run closer to $6 to $9 per square foot, but their exposed screws need attention every decade or so.
How long each one lasts
A good architectural shingle roof lasts 20 to 30 years. Sun and heat do the wearing: the granules wash off, the shingles curl, and eventually they stop shedding water the way they should. A metal roof lasts 40 to 70 years. It does not rot, crack, or lose granules. That is the whole case for metal in one sentence — you pay for two shingle roofs' worth of years in a single installation. But lifespan only matters if you stay. A 50-year roof on a house you sell in eight years bought you nothing the buyer will pay extra for.
What storms do to each
Hail treats them differently. Hail cracks and bruises shingles, knocking the granules off and shortening the roof's life even when it does not leak right away. The same hail dents metal — visible dimples, usually cosmetic, rarely a leak. That difference matters twice: once for the roof, and once for the insurance claim, because insurers may call metal dents cosmetic and pay little for them. Wind favors metal. A standing-seam roof locks together at the seams and holds in winds that strip shingles off — most metal systems are rated to 140 miles per hour and beyond, while shingles start lifting around 110 to 130. In wildfire country, metal does not burn. In snow country, metal sheds snow in sheets, which spares the roof the weight but can dump a slide onto a walkway — snow guards fix that.
The worries that do not matter much
Noise is the first worry, and it is mostly settled: a metal roof over a normal deck with underlayment and attic insulation is not noticeably louder than shingles in rain. The barn-roof drumming people imagine comes from metal over open framing, which is not how a house is built. Looks are settled too — modern metal comes in shingle and tile profiles and dozens of colors. The worry that is real is the shape of your roof. Metal is at its best on a simple roof — long straight runs, few valleys, few dormers. Every valley, chimney, and skylight is a hand-cut seam, and the installer's hours climb fast. On a roof cut up into a dozen little planes, shingles are usually the cheaper and simpler answer.
Doing the math on your own roof
Forget the sticker price and divide by the years. A $12,000 shingle roof that lasts 25 years costs about $480 a year. A $26,000 metal roof that lasts 50 years costs about $520 a year — close to a wash, and the metal roof is still there at year 26, when the second shingle roof would cost another $12,000 or more. That math still favors shingles in two cases: if you will move before the first shingle roof wears out, or if the money is not there now. Before you decide, check your homeowners association, which sometimes restricts metal, and your insurer, which sometimes discounts metal roofs — a discount that narrows the gap every year you stay.
Which one fits your house
Pick shingles if you plan to sell within ten years, if the budget is tight, or if your roof is a maze of valleys and dormers. Pick metal if you plan to stay twenty years or more, if your roof is a simple shape, or if hail, high wind, wildfire, or heavy snow is a regular part of life where you live. Either way, the material is only half the job — a bad install leaks in five years in shingles and one in metal. Get the roofer's references, ask how many roofs of that exact material they have installed, and get the warranty in writing — the manufacturer's covers the material, the installer's covers the workmanship, and they are not the same thing.
See your roof the way a roofer does — free.
Start with a free aerial exam of your roof: a full look at every slope, with a plain-English report of what is damaged and what it will take to fix it. If it needs a closer look, book a free in-person inspection — schedule online at Tryroofrover.com.
Get My Free Aerial Exam →The bottom line
Metal costs about twice as much and lasts about twice as long; shingles cost less now and do the job for twenty to thirty years. If you are staying put and your roof is a simple shape, metal is the cheaper roof over the life of the house. If you are selling soon or the budget is tight, shingles are the right call — and the installer matters more than the material either way.